Supreme Court Ruled Inherited IRAs Not Exempt

huntsville Attorney Mary Conner PoolThe Supreme Court made an important ruling in 2014 concerning inherited IRAs.   In Clark v. Rameker , the Court unanimously held that unlike a self-funded IRA, an inherited IRA is not protected in bankruptcy.

When a debtor files bankruptcy, he may exempt certain things from his bankruptcy estate. Any property that falls under an exemption is not available for distribution to creditors.  The exemption in question in this case allows debtors to protect “retirement funds to the extent those funds are in a fund or account that is exempt from taxation under section 401, 403, 408, 408A, 414, 457, or 501(a) of the Internal Revenue Code.” §§522(b)(3)(C),(d)(12).  Those sections of the Internal Revenue Code include IRAs, Roth IRAs, and inherited IRAs.

The case heard by the Supreme Court involved a woman, Heidi Heffron-Clark, who declared bankruptcy in 2010.  Heffron-Clark and her husband claimed that the IRA she inherited from her mother qualified as “retirement funds” and was exempted from her bankruptcy estate.   This would mean that the IRA- worth about $300,000 at the time of their bankruptcy filing- would not be available to creditors.

The bankruptcy trustee and unsecured creditors filed suit against the Heffron-Clark and her husband, saying that they could not claim these funds as exempt.  The bankruptcy court agreed.  The inherited account, the bankruptcy court concluded, did not hold anyone’s “retirement funds.”  The account was merely a source of revenue for Heffron-Clark.  The case was appealed and eventually reached the Supreme Court.

Differences Between IRAs and Inherited IRAs

The Supreme Court pointed out the differences in an inherited IRA and a regular IRA.  Unlike a regular self-funded IRA, a person who inherits an IRA can withdraw money at any time.  In fact, funds must be withdrawn from an inherited IRA at least annually.  Additionally, a person who holds an inherited IRA cannot contribute to the account.  Accordingly, Heffron-Clark never contributed to the IRA in question in this case, and had withdrawn about $150,000 from it since 2001.

The Court then looked to the purpose of the exemption of retirement funds.  The exemption is set out in the Bankruptcy Code so that debtors will be able to meet their basic needs during their retirement years.  With an inherited IRA, funds must be withdrawn immediately.  The Supreme Court said that the plain meaning of the Bankruptcy Code was that funds a person sets aside for their own retirement should be exempted, not funds that are inherited and can be used immediately.  The Court concluded that inherited IRAs are not “retirement funds” and do not receive the same protection in bankruptcy.

If you have questions about your IRA and filing bankruptcy, contact one of our offices and set up an appointment to discuss with one of our attorneys.

 

Related Articles

 

Share This Page

Bond & Botes Law Offices

At Bond & Botes, we now offer full service bankruptcy consultation and filing over the phone or by video from the comfort and safety of your home or office. Please call 1-877-581-3396 or click here to setup your free phone or video consultation.

The lawyers at the Bond & Botes affiliated offices serve clients at offices in Anniston, Birmingham, Mobile, Montgomery, Opelika, Decatur, Huntsville, Florence, Haleyville and Gadsden, Alabama; Vicksburg, Hattiesburg and Jackson, Mississippi. Read our disclaimer here. You can view our Privacy Policy here.

Alabama Offices

Birmingham

2107 5th Avenue North
Age-Herald Building
Birmingham, Alabama 35203
Phone: (205) 802-2200


Shelby County Location
15 Southlake Lane, Ste 140
Birmingham, AL 35244
Phone: (205) 802-2200


Florence Location
121 S. Court Street
Florence, AL 35630
Phone: (256) 760-1010


Huntsville Location
225 Pratt Avenue NE
Huntsville, AL 35801
Phone: (256) 539-9899


Montgomery Location
311 Catoma Street
Montgomery, AL 36104
Phone: (334) 264-3363


Decatur Location
605 Bank Street
Decatur, AL 35601
Phone: (256) 355-2447


Haleyville Location
914 19th St.
Haleyville, AL 35565
Phone: (205) 486-3580


Gadsden Location
430-B Chestnut Street
Gadsden, AL 35901
Phone: (256) 485-0195


Opelika Location
216 South 8th Street
Opelika 36801
Phone: (334) 887-7666


Anniston Location
1302 Noble St #2C
Anniston, AL 36201
Phone: (256) 344-3559


Cullman Location
200 Second Avenue SW
Cullman, AL 35055
Phone: (256) 739-9866


Mississippi Offices

Jackson Location
5760 I-55 North, Ste 100
Jackson, MS 39211
Phone: (601) 353-5000


Hattiesburg Location
607 Corinne St, Ste B8
Hattiesburg, MS 39401
Phone: (601) 264-7200


Vicksburg Location
1212 Farmer Street
Vicksburg, MS 39180
Phone: (601) 353-5000

© 2024 by Bond & Botes Law Offices. All rights reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy